Posted on Thursday 1 May 2008
McGonagall was born in Edinburgh of Irish parents and gave up his job as a handloom weaver in Dundee to become a poet. Others did not value his lyricism as much as he did himself and he died penniless in 1902.
His bad rhymes and remarkable self-regard earned him his notorious reputation, as Scottish poet Hugh MacDiarmid comments, “William McGonagall wasn’t a bad poet; still less a good bad poet. He was not a poet at all…”
Whilst the clunky banality of his verse may not have touched hearts in the way he would have liked, it has inspired a plethora of parody, like this rhyme by Kathy and Ross Petras, co-editors of the book Very Bad Poetry; “with all due respect to the poor McGonagall, one is forced to agree; the man transgresses so many rules of rhyme, meter, taste, style, it’s a wonder he wasn’t shot for crimes against poetry.”
Nevertheless, he finally seems to be garnering the interest that he was always so certain he deserved and he has gathered quite a cult following. His present day fans include JK Rowling, who named Harry Potter’s teacher Professor McGonagall.
The poems, sold by an unnamed private collector, will go under the hammer in one lot, include 15 originals not held by the National Library of Scotland and have an impressive estimate of £4,500 - £6,500.









